I opened my Amazon seller account on 01/07/2014. I've been selling here for over 12 years.
The reality is I could have sold 10 times the volume I have over those years if I had wanted to aggressively scale. Instead, I've always tried to keep things manageable, take care of customers, and maintain a clean account.
I'm a very small-volume seller, so one defect can have a massive impact on my business. Yesterday I shipped an order on time, but I forgot to enter the tracking number. The package is already on its way to the customer and will be delivered without issue, but because I missed that one step, I now have a defect and have effectively lost the Buy Box again for 30 days.
What makes this so discouraging is that it feels like none of my history matters. I've spent 12 years building my account, maintaining good metrics, and trying to do things the right way. One simple oversight seems to outweigh more than a decade of good performance.
I'm not trying to avoid responsibility. I made the mistake and I own it. I just wish there was some consideration for seller history and overall performance. Most ecommerce platforms I've sold on seem to look at the bigger picture. Amazon often feels completely unforgiving, especially for low volume sellers.
My question is whether Seller Support ever takes a seller's long-term history into account when reviewing situations like this. Has anyone had success getting a defect removed when the item was shipped on time and the only issue was forgetting to upload tracking?
Maybe I'm just venting, but after 12 years of selling, it's hard not to feel defeated when one small oversight seems to outweigh years of doing the right thing.