case id 16899116741

I am writing to bring your attention to a 2-star Amazon Vine review on our product name MEGA PATCH ASIN B0DJLBJFT4. I believe this review violates Amazon’s Vine Program guidelines and community review policies. Its content, associated with the trusted Amazon Vine tag, is vague, unsupported, and potentially misleading to customers.

The credibility of this reviewer's writing style is also in question. As a seller I don't see him doing vine reviews for many other products.

Below are the specific reasons I believe the review should be reconsidered for removal:

Review Details

Rating: 2 Stars

Review Title: "They don't do anything"

Review Body:

"Tried these out on a couple of pimples, hoping they would work like all the other pimple patches, reducing pain/irritation and shrinking them over time so I didn't have to pop them, aaaand they kind of made them worse. They didn't disappear, the pain got worse, and kind of just made the area soggy. Would not purchase again."

Reviewer Name:

David J

ASIN: B0DJLBJFT4

Reasons for Policy Violation

Subjective and Unsupported Claims:

The reviewer states that the product "made the area soggy" and "kind of made them worse" without providing any factual or detailed feedback about their experience.

Amazon Vine reviews are intended to be insightful, constructive, and helpful for other shoppers. This review falls short of those standards, offering little actionable information while potentially confusing or misleading future buyers.Also creating a biased judgement on the product

Potential Misuse of the Product:

The review does not specify whether the product was used in line with the clear instructions provided.

The Mega Patch is explicitly designed for clean, dry skin and is most effective on whiteheads or pimples with visible heads. Improper use or applying the product to incompatible skin conditions could lead to the described experience, which is not a reflection of the product’s actual quality or effectiveness.

Misrepresentation of Product Performance:

The broad statement that the product “doesn’t do anything” directly contradicts both the product’s scientifically-backed formulation and positive feedback from many other customers.

This misrepresentation can unfairly deter potential buyers and tarnish the brand’s credibility despite the product’s proven benefits.

Vague and Unhelpful Feedback:

Phrases such as "kind of made them worse" and "kind of made the area soggy" lack clarity and fail to provide meaningful insights for other shoppers.

The Vine Program encourages detailed, informative reviews that allow customers to make well-informed purchasing decisions. This review fails to meet that expectation, offering no constructive critique or suggestions for improvement.

Impact of the Amazon Vine Tag on My Brand

As a small business, I rely on customer trust to maintain a positive brand reputation. Reviews tagged with the Amazon Vine badge are given higher credibility by customers due to their association with Amazon’s trusted program. This review’s vague, unsupported, and potentially misleading content could:

Unfairly dissuade potential buyers, creating unwarranted doubts about the product’s effectiveness.

Erode trust in the Amazon Vine Program by promoting non constructive feedback as credible.

Damage my brand’s reputation, as the Vine tag adds undue weight to an otherwise unsupported and unhelpful critique.

Please consider my request as brand owner and partner seller at amazon.