Seller Forums
user profile
Seller_b5yea9JwP3v1V

False Counterfeit Accusations from Amazon Cost Me $20K+ -- And They Do Nothing????

I am an Amazon seller facing an unprecedented issue that has caused significant financial and reputational damage to my business.

Here’s what happened: on November 13, 2024, due to an error on my product listing, Amazon flagged my product as violating intellectual property rights. AS the mention of this TM was a technical error during ASIN creation, I immediately corrected it. Amazon reinstated the listing, seemingly resolving the issue. Account Health Specialists also assured me that day the ASIN is good to go.

However, Amazon then sent over 1,500 automatic emails to my customers falsely accusing me of selling counterfeit for that TM. With no prior investigation Amazon labeled my product as 'counterfirt recalled' and asked customers 'not give this product to your pets and dispose of it', aslo 'seek veterinary advice'. NO. PRIOR. INVESTIGATION.

This resulted in $20,615.62 in automatic refunds, including refunds for unrelated products, with no proper notification. This day still, I HAVE NOT BEEN OFFICIALLY NOTIFIED.

Not only this case seemd to be illegal from Intellectual Property Law, this situation also violates Amazon’s 'Product Safety and Recalls' policy. Namely, the following article was totally ignored 'We promptly inform both customers and sellers about the recall or safety alert.'.

To address this situation, I reached out to multiple external and internal channels:

- Filed a complaint with the Better Business Bureau (BBB),

- Submitted a detailed case to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC),

- Contacted the State Attorney General’s Office,

- Sent personal emails to Amazon’s C-level executives,

- Opened multiple cases through Amazon’s Selling Partner Support.

Despite these extensive efforts, none of these actions have led to a resolution. BBB, the FTC, and the Attorney General's Office have not been able to compel Amazon to take corrective action. Internally, Amazon’s support agents have repeatedly stated that "this matter does not fall under Selling Partner Support’s responsibilities" or given inconsistent responses, leaving me without any path forward.

Amazon’s baseless accusations have caused significant financial harm, irreparably damaged my reputation, and destroyed trust with my customers. I am sharing my experience to expose the systemic failures that allow small businesses like mine to be crushed under false accusations and lack of accountability.

I need advice:

1) Has anyone else experienced similar treatment?

2) What additional steps can I take to hold Amazon accountable and recover my financial losses?

I hope this post will not only shed light on this issue but also prompt Amazon to address their unjust actions. Shame on you.

1.1K views
32 replies
Tags:Counterfeit, Counterfeit Crimes Unit, Intellectual property infringements
330
Reply
user profile
Seller_b5yea9JwP3v1V

False Counterfeit Accusations from Amazon Cost Me $20K+ -- And They Do Nothing????

I am an Amazon seller facing an unprecedented issue that has caused significant financial and reputational damage to my business.

Here’s what happened: on November 13, 2024, due to an error on my product listing, Amazon flagged my product as violating intellectual property rights. AS the mention of this TM was a technical error during ASIN creation, I immediately corrected it. Amazon reinstated the listing, seemingly resolving the issue. Account Health Specialists also assured me that day the ASIN is good to go.

However, Amazon then sent over 1,500 automatic emails to my customers falsely accusing me of selling counterfeit for that TM. With no prior investigation Amazon labeled my product as 'counterfirt recalled' and asked customers 'not give this product to your pets and dispose of it', aslo 'seek veterinary advice'. NO. PRIOR. INVESTIGATION.

This resulted in $20,615.62 in automatic refunds, including refunds for unrelated products, with no proper notification. This day still, I HAVE NOT BEEN OFFICIALLY NOTIFIED.

Not only this case seemd to be illegal from Intellectual Property Law, this situation also violates Amazon’s 'Product Safety and Recalls' policy. Namely, the following article was totally ignored 'We promptly inform both customers and sellers about the recall or safety alert.'.

To address this situation, I reached out to multiple external and internal channels:

- Filed a complaint with the Better Business Bureau (BBB),

- Submitted a detailed case to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC),

- Contacted the State Attorney General’s Office,

- Sent personal emails to Amazon’s C-level executives,

- Opened multiple cases through Amazon’s Selling Partner Support.

Despite these extensive efforts, none of these actions have led to a resolution. BBB, the FTC, and the Attorney General's Office have not been able to compel Amazon to take corrective action. Internally, Amazon’s support agents have repeatedly stated that "this matter does not fall under Selling Partner Support’s responsibilities" or given inconsistent responses, leaving me without any path forward.

Amazon’s baseless accusations have caused significant financial harm, irreparably damaged my reputation, and destroyed trust with my customers. I am sharing my experience to expose the systemic failures that allow small businesses like mine to be crushed under false accusations and lack of accountability.

I need advice:

1) Has anyone else experienced similar treatment?

2) What additional steps can I take to hold Amazon accountable and recover my financial losses?

I hope this post will not only shed light on this issue but also prompt Amazon to address their unjust actions. Shame on you.

Tags:Counterfeit, Counterfeit Crimes Unit, Intellectual property infringements
330
1.1K views
32 replies
Reply
32 replies
user profile
Seller_rI7BZIczK8iAC

That sounds frightening and your anger is understandable. It looks like you have to take professional help from an Amazon attorney. He has to contact Amazon's Legal Office.

Also it's strange that a TM issue should cause a safety issue... complicated situation.

user profile
Seller_b5yea9JwP3v1V
asked customers 'not give this product to your pets and dispose of it', aslo 'seek veterinary advice'.
View post
51
user profile
Seller_MyXY4Myx9zVcR

You need to hire an attorney if you don't already have one.

120
user profile
Seller_Ha6JyVvDK6Ybs

When you dance with the FBA Devil you will always get burned.

71
user profile
Seller_SJRMV3s4mNrFA

Really simple case to win.

Judge: Did you contact the seller to see if it was a mistake?

Amazon: No

Judge: Did you do any testing to see if it was counterfeit?

Amazon: No

Judge: Total Freakin' Negligence on Amazon's part. Summary judgement in favor of the Plantiff for whatever amount they ask.

be sure to ask for punitive damages also

100
user profile
Seller_fvyYWxtfKdLCj

It is slowly starting to tumble at Amazon. From anti-trust to nuanced problems like this, I've been seeing the writing on the wall!

Like everyone else said, seek legal help. It really seems like this will work in your favor, hopefully it doesn't drag! Wish you the best of luck.

30
user profile
Seller_3SMNTppfRyw6p

Wow.. I'm in complete shock.

We call on Amazon to pay attention to this egregious situation!

30
user profile
Seller_mamQyyX3u7LDf

Amazon is beyond themselves

first they falsely get your listing down, but then they also charge you for it????? for 20k+???

AMAZON PAY ATTENTION AND SAVE THIS GUY, YOU ARE WRONG

20
user profile
Seller_KYFSTPmCWyMrv

Man I am so sorry you have to go trhough this..

Amazon is 100% wrong here, nothing to do with your product. Just a typical e-com..

I am sure this is quite an easy legal take, yet if you decide to go with Amazon Support this sounds like a loong road.. Take care and keep us posted

30
user profile
Seller_b5yea9JwP3v1V

False Counterfeit Accusations from Amazon Cost Me $20K+ -- And They Do Nothing????

I am an Amazon seller facing an unprecedented issue that has caused significant financial and reputational damage to my business.

Here’s what happened: on November 13, 2024, due to an error on my product listing, Amazon flagged my product as violating intellectual property rights. AS the mention of this TM was a technical error during ASIN creation, I immediately corrected it. Amazon reinstated the listing, seemingly resolving the issue. Account Health Specialists also assured me that day the ASIN is good to go.

However, Amazon then sent over 1,500 automatic emails to my customers falsely accusing me of selling counterfeit for that TM. With no prior investigation Amazon labeled my product as 'counterfirt recalled' and asked customers 'not give this product to your pets and dispose of it', aslo 'seek veterinary advice'. NO. PRIOR. INVESTIGATION.

This resulted in $20,615.62 in automatic refunds, including refunds for unrelated products, with no proper notification. This day still, I HAVE NOT BEEN OFFICIALLY NOTIFIED.

Not only this case seemd to be illegal from Intellectual Property Law, this situation also violates Amazon’s 'Product Safety and Recalls' policy. Namely, the following article was totally ignored 'We promptly inform both customers and sellers about the recall or safety alert.'.

To address this situation, I reached out to multiple external and internal channels:

- Filed a complaint with the Better Business Bureau (BBB),

- Submitted a detailed case to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC),

- Contacted the State Attorney General’s Office,

- Sent personal emails to Amazon’s C-level executives,

- Opened multiple cases through Amazon’s Selling Partner Support.

Despite these extensive efforts, none of these actions have led to a resolution. BBB, the FTC, and the Attorney General's Office have not been able to compel Amazon to take corrective action. Internally, Amazon’s support agents have repeatedly stated that "this matter does not fall under Selling Partner Support’s responsibilities" or given inconsistent responses, leaving me without any path forward.

Amazon’s baseless accusations have caused significant financial harm, irreparably damaged my reputation, and destroyed trust with my customers. I am sharing my experience to expose the systemic failures that allow small businesses like mine to be crushed under false accusations and lack of accountability.

I need advice:

1) Has anyone else experienced similar treatment?

2) What additional steps can I take to hold Amazon accountable and recover my financial losses?

I hope this post will not only shed light on this issue but also prompt Amazon to address their unjust actions. Shame on you.

1.1K views
32 replies
Tags:Counterfeit, Counterfeit Crimes Unit, Intellectual property infringements
330
Reply
user profile
Seller_b5yea9JwP3v1V

False Counterfeit Accusations from Amazon Cost Me $20K+ -- And They Do Nothing????

I am an Amazon seller facing an unprecedented issue that has caused significant financial and reputational damage to my business.

Here’s what happened: on November 13, 2024, due to an error on my product listing, Amazon flagged my product as violating intellectual property rights. AS the mention of this TM was a technical error during ASIN creation, I immediately corrected it. Amazon reinstated the listing, seemingly resolving the issue. Account Health Specialists also assured me that day the ASIN is good to go.

However, Amazon then sent over 1,500 automatic emails to my customers falsely accusing me of selling counterfeit for that TM. With no prior investigation Amazon labeled my product as 'counterfirt recalled' and asked customers 'not give this product to your pets and dispose of it', aslo 'seek veterinary advice'. NO. PRIOR. INVESTIGATION.

This resulted in $20,615.62 in automatic refunds, including refunds for unrelated products, with no proper notification. This day still, I HAVE NOT BEEN OFFICIALLY NOTIFIED.

Not only this case seemd to be illegal from Intellectual Property Law, this situation also violates Amazon’s 'Product Safety and Recalls' policy. Namely, the following article was totally ignored 'We promptly inform both customers and sellers about the recall or safety alert.'.

To address this situation, I reached out to multiple external and internal channels:

- Filed a complaint with the Better Business Bureau (BBB),

- Submitted a detailed case to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC),

- Contacted the State Attorney General’s Office,

- Sent personal emails to Amazon’s C-level executives,

- Opened multiple cases through Amazon’s Selling Partner Support.

Despite these extensive efforts, none of these actions have led to a resolution. BBB, the FTC, and the Attorney General's Office have not been able to compel Amazon to take corrective action. Internally, Amazon’s support agents have repeatedly stated that "this matter does not fall under Selling Partner Support’s responsibilities" or given inconsistent responses, leaving me without any path forward.

Amazon’s baseless accusations have caused significant financial harm, irreparably damaged my reputation, and destroyed trust with my customers. I am sharing my experience to expose the systemic failures that allow small businesses like mine to be crushed under false accusations and lack of accountability.

I need advice:

1) Has anyone else experienced similar treatment?

2) What additional steps can I take to hold Amazon accountable and recover my financial losses?

I hope this post will not only shed light on this issue but also prompt Amazon to address their unjust actions. Shame on you.

Tags:Counterfeit, Counterfeit Crimes Unit, Intellectual property infringements
330
1.1K views
32 replies
Reply
user profile

False Counterfeit Accusations from Amazon Cost Me $20K+ -- And They Do Nothing????

by Seller_b5yea9JwP3v1V

I am an Amazon seller facing an unprecedented issue that has caused significant financial and reputational damage to my business.

Here’s what happened: on November 13, 2024, due to an error on my product listing, Amazon flagged my product as violating intellectual property rights. AS the mention of this TM was a technical error during ASIN creation, I immediately corrected it. Amazon reinstated the listing, seemingly resolving the issue. Account Health Specialists also assured me that day the ASIN is good to go.

However, Amazon then sent over 1,500 automatic emails to my customers falsely accusing me of selling counterfeit for that TM. With no prior investigation Amazon labeled my product as 'counterfirt recalled' and asked customers 'not give this product to your pets and dispose of it', aslo 'seek veterinary advice'. NO. PRIOR. INVESTIGATION.

This resulted in $20,615.62 in automatic refunds, including refunds for unrelated products, with no proper notification. This day still, I HAVE NOT BEEN OFFICIALLY NOTIFIED.

Not only this case seemd to be illegal from Intellectual Property Law, this situation also violates Amazon’s 'Product Safety and Recalls' policy. Namely, the following article was totally ignored 'We promptly inform both customers and sellers about the recall or safety alert.'.

To address this situation, I reached out to multiple external and internal channels:

- Filed a complaint with the Better Business Bureau (BBB),

- Submitted a detailed case to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC),

- Contacted the State Attorney General’s Office,

- Sent personal emails to Amazon’s C-level executives,

- Opened multiple cases through Amazon’s Selling Partner Support.

Despite these extensive efforts, none of these actions have led to a resolution. BBB, the FTC, and the Attorney General's Office have not been able to compel Amazon to take corrective action. Internally, Amazon’s support agents have repeatedly stated that "this matter does not fall under Selling Partner Support’s responsibilities" or given inconsistent responses, leaving me without any path forward.

Amazon’s baseless accusations have caused significant financial harm, irreparably damaged my reputation, and destroyed trust with my customers. I am sharing my experience to expose the systemic failures that allow small businesses like mine to be crushed under false accusations and lack of accountability.

I need advice:

1) Has anyone else experienced similar treatment?

2) What additional steps can I take to hold Amazon accountable and recover my financial losses?

I hope this post will not only shed light on this issue but also prompt Amazon to address their unjust actions. Shame on you.

Tags:Counterfeit, Counterfeit Crimes Unit, Intellectual property infringements
330
1.1K views
32 replies
Reply
32 replies
32 replies
Quick filters
Sort by
user profile
Seller_rI7BZIczK8iAC

That sounds frightening and your anger is understandable. It looks like you have to take professional help from an Amazon attorney. He has to contact Amazon's Legal Office.

Also it's strange that a TM issue should cause a safety issue... complicated situation.

user profile
Seller_b5yea9JwP3v1V
asked customers 'not give this product to your pets and dispose of it', aslo 'seek veterinary advice'.
View post
51
user profile
Seller_MyXY4Myx9zVcR

You need to hire an attorney if you don't already have one.

120
user profile
Seller_Ha6JyVvDK6Ybs

When you dance with the FBA Devil you will always get burned.

71
user profile
Seller_SJRMV3s4mNrFA

Really simple case to win.

Judge: Did you contact the seller to see if it was a mistake?

Amazon: No

Judge: Did you do any testing to see if it was counterfeit?

Amazon: No

Judge: Total Freakin' Negligence on Amazon's part. Summary judgement in favor of the Plantiff for whatever amount they ask.

be sure to ask for punitive damages also

100
user profile
Seller_fvyYWxtfKdLCj

It is slowly starting to tumble at Amazon. From anti-trust to nuanced problems like this, I've been seeing the writing on the wall!

Like everyone else said, seek legal help. It really seems like this will work in your favor, hopefully it doesn't drag! Wish you the best of luck.

30
user profile
Seller_3SMNTppfRyw6p

Wow.. I'm in complete shock.

We call on Amazon to pay attention to this egregious situation!

30
user profile
Seller_mamQyyX3u7LDf

Amazon is beyond themselves

first they falsely get your listing down, but then they also charge you for it????? for 20k+???

AMAZON PAY ATTENTION AND SAVE THIS GUY, YOU ARE WRONG

20
user profile
Seller_KYFSTPmCWyMrv

Man I am so sorry you have to go trhough this..

Amazon is 100% wrong here, nothing to do with your product. Just a typical e-com..

I am sure this is quite an easy legal take, yet if you decide to go with Amazon Support this sounds like a loong road.. Take care and keep us posted

30
user profile
Seller_rI7BZIczK8iAC

That sounds frightening and your anger is understandable. It looks like you have to take professional help from an Amazon attorney. He has to contact Amazon's Legal Office.

Also it's strange that a TM issue should cause a safety issue... complicated situation.

user profile
Seller_b5yea9JwP3v1V
asked customers 'not give this product to your pets and dispose of it', aslo 'seek veterinary advice'.
View post
51
user profile
Seller_rI7BZIczK8iAC

That sounds frightening and your anger is understandable. It looks like you have to take professional help from an Amazon attorney. He has to contact Amazon's Legal Office.

Also it's strange that a TM issue should cause a safety issue... complicated situation.

user profile
Seller_b5yea9JwP3v1V
asked customers 'not give this product to your pets and dispose of it', aslo 'seek veterinary advice'.
View post
51
Reply
user profile
Seller_MyXY4Myx9zVcR

You need to hire an attorney if you don't already have one.

120
user profile
Seller_MyXY4Myx9zVcR

You need to hire an attorney if you don't already have one.

120
Reply
user profile
Seller_Ha6JyVvDK6Ybs

When you dance with the FBA Devil you will always get burned.

71
user profile
Seller_Ha6JyVvDK6Ybs

When you dance with the FBA Devil you will always get burned.

71
Reply
user profile
Seller_SJRMV3s4mNrFA

Really simple case to win.

Judge: Did you contact the seller to see if it was a mistake?

Amazon: No

Judge: Did you do any testing to see if it was counterfeit?

Amazon: No

Judge: Total Freakin' Negligence on Amazon's part. Summary judgement in favor of the Plantiff for whatever amount they ask.

be sure to ask for punitive damages also

100
user profile
Seller_SJRMV3s4mNrFA

Really simple case to win.

Judge: Did you contact the seller to see if it was a mistake?

Amazon: No

Judge: Did you do any testing to see if it was counterfeit?

Amazon: No

Judge: Total Freakin' Negligence on Amazon's part. Summary judgement in favor of the Plantiff for whatever amount they ask.

be sure to ask for punitive damages also

100
Reply
user profile
Seller_fvyYWxtfKdLCj

It is slowly starting to tumble at Amazon. From anti-trust to nuanced problems like this, I've been seeing the writing on the wall!

Like everyone else said, seek legal help. It really seems like this will work in your favor, hopefully it doesn't drag! Wish you the best of luck.

30
user profile
Seller_fvyYWxtfKdLCj

It is slowly starting to tumble at Amazon. From anti-trust to nuanced problems like this, I've been seeing the writing on the wall!

Like everyone else said, seek legal help. It really seems like this will work in your favor, hopefully it doesn't drag! Wish you the best of luck.

30
Reply
user profile
Seller_3SMNTppfRyw6p

Wow.. I'm in complete shock.

We call on Amazon to pay attention to this egregious situation!

30
user profile
Seller_3SMNTppfRyw6p

Wow.. I'm in complete shock.

We call on Amazon to pay attention to this egregious situation!

30
Reply
user profile
Seller_mamQyyX3u7LDf

Amazon is beyond themselves

first they falsely get your listing down, but then they also charge you for it????? for 20k+???

AMAZON PAY ATTENTION AND SAVE THIS GUY, YOU ARE WRONG

20
user profile
Seller_mamQyyX3u7LDf

Amazon is beyond themselves

first they falsely get your listing down, but then they also charge you for it????? for 20k+???

AMAZON PAY ATTENTION AND SAVE THIS GUY, YOU ARE WRONG

20
Reply
user profile
Seller_KYFSTPmCWyMrv

Man I am so sorry you have to go trhough this..

Amazon is 100% wrong here, nothing to do with your product. Just a typical e-com..

I am sure this is quite an easy legal take, yet if you decide to go with Amazon Support this sounds like a loong road.. Take care and keep us posted

30
user profile
Seller_KYFSTPmCWyMrv

Man I am so sorry you have to go trhough this..

Amazon is 100% wrong here, nothing to do with your product. Just a typical e-com..

I am sure this is quite an easy legal take, yet if you decide to go with Amazon Support this sounds like a loong road.. Take care and keep us posted

30
Reply