Seller Forums
Sign in
Sign in
user profile
Sign in
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

1000 plus Hijacked 5 star verified purchase reviews on a single product

Main ASIN B074XDNLWZ
Eyelash Growth Serum for Lash and Brow Irritation by AsaVea

2,718 customer reviews

HIJACKED ASINS that are

  • joined as a variation under a single parent
  • out of stock
  • unrelated products with lots of real verified 5 star reviews
  • original brand overwritten to AsaVera brand
  • thus reviews for those products appear under the main asin

ASIN B00BV9B3R8 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink)
ASIN B01E1N975K 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
ASIN B01KW6GJR4 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
ASIN B013KVZT10 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)
ASIN B00GXFRF8Q 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)
ASIN B00GMOVWQE 87 reviews(5 star, Color: 1ml)
ASIN B00GMA8BNU 79 reviews(5 star, Color: a )

1408 total co-opted 5 Star reviews from unrelated products

We have been hijacked by this brand, more than one of our items so I need to defend and report the violation

Can someone help me determine what are these violations called in the proper terminology so I can give seller performance a proper name for this - besides co-opting a listing it will be one or more of these:

twister-abuse,
variation-abuse,
self-hijacking,
asin-adoption,
shadow-invisible

Thank you in advance!

For those who are experiencing the same issue

I will post ( IN THIS THREAD ) a simple HOW-TO for finding the co-opted ASINs so you can defend your listings efficiently

2.2K views
32 replies
Tags:ASIN, Images, Listing hijack, Listings, SKU
50
Reply
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

1000 plus Hijacked 5 star verified purchase reviews on a single product

Main ASIN B074XDNLWZ
Eyelash Growth Serum for Lash and Brow Irritation by AsaVea

2,718 customer reviews

HIJACKED ASINS that are

  • joined as a variation under a single parent
  • out of stock
  • unrelated products with lots of real verified 5 star reviews
  • original brand overwritten to AsaVera brand
  • thus reviews for those products appear under the main asin

ASIN B00BV9B3R8 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink)
ASIN B01E1N975K 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
ASIN B01KW6GJR4 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
ASIN B013KVZT10 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)
ASIN B00GXFRF8Q 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)
ASIN B00GMOVWQE 87 reviews(5 star, Color: 1ml)
ASIN B00GMA8BNU 79 reviews(5 star, Color: a )

1408 total co-opted 5 Star reviews from unrelated products

We have been hijacked by this brand, more than one of our items so I need to defend and report the violation

Can someone help me determine what are these violations called in the proper terminology so I can give seller performance a proper name for this - besides co-opting a listing it will be one or more of these:

twister-abuse,
variation-abuse,
self-hijacking,
asin-adoption,
shadow-invisible

Thank you in advance!

For those who are experiencing the same issue

I will post ( IN THIS THREAD ) a simple HOW-TO for finding the co-opted ASINs so you can defend your listings efficiently

2.2K views
32 replies
Tags:ASIN, Images, Listing hijack, Listings, SKU
50
Reply
32 replies
user profile
Seller_Zw8LsZUQSH440

Amazon has no interest in stopping this practice. Violation reports are ignored and both customers and sellers are ripped off. Not to mention the fact that these cosmetics products may be dangerous.

20
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

Here is a simple how-to find hijacked unrelated ASINS when a seller co-opted your listings and changed images, brand, title to hijack your product reviews

for example


look at ASIN B074XDNLWZ
Eyelash Growth Serum for Lash and Brow Irritation by AsaVea
2,718 customer reviews
wow that’s a lot of reviews

MOST IMPORTANT STEP 1

click on the 5 star reviews


scroll down to the actual reviews and right before VERIFIED PURCHASE you will see if the review is for variation X or variation Y etc…

this one has the following variations
COLOR: 3 ML
Reading those reviews, they are for eyelash growth serum those are the real reviews that belong to the hijacker’s ASIN- so skip over those and
keep on scrolling down THOSE 5 STAR REVIEWS till you see a review for another variation
Evantually on page 2 of the 5 star reviews you will see a review for
Variation ----> Color: Cute Pink

STEP 2

so click on the Color: Cute Pink - IT IS A LINK AND IT WILL SEGREGATE JUST THE REVIEWS FOR VARIATION COLOR CUTE PINK
THEN IN THE WEB address IT WILL SHOW YOU THE ASIN NUMBER OF THAT VARIATION
SO COLOR CUTE PINK IS ASIN B00BV9B3R8
Now we will see the reviews just for that variation only ( if you clicked on the Color: Cute Pink link in the reviews )


Scroll down under the filter buttons on that review page, you will see
Showing 1-10 of 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink).

… and all the reviews that are for the Amazon Fire case, i-UniK Amazon Fire 7" Display Wi-Fi which was hijacked by AsaVea and subsequently they changed the CUTE PINK FIRE CASE to Peel Off Mask and AsaVea brand and joined it as a ghost variation to their EYELASH product

STEP 3

Record the Hijacked ASIN from the web address of the reviews, in this case it is
ASIN B00BV9B3R8
Record number of hijacked reviews 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink).

RINSE AND REPEAT STEP 1 THROUGH 3 TILL YOU HAVE ENOUGH ASINS THAT WERE HIJACKED TO SUBMIT YOUR REPORT

… go back to all 5 star reviews


keep going to page 2 or 3 till you see

next variation is
Color: e
Click on that color e
that will get you to this page
which is for ASIN B01E1N975K
and under the sort buttons you will see
Showing 1-10 of 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
and all those reviews are for nail clippers ASIN B01E1N975K

NEXT YOU MAY WANT TO RUN THAT ASIN B01E1N975K THROUGH GOOGLE AND YOU WILL SEE THAT ASIN USED TO BE
google cache for asin B01E1N975K
Nail Clipper Set with Nail File and Buffer, Fingernail and Toenail Clippers by Sensible Needs - Nail Cutters - Manicure Set

then we can step over back to ALL 5star reveiws
and find the next variation
now we have
Color: Amber
click on Color Amber and you will get reviews for the Color: Amber
you will get
so this one is ASIN B01KW6GJR4
Showing 1-10 of 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
That ASIN used to be: Pure Organic Jojoba Oil (2 Oz.) Best Quality Oil For

Next going back to all 5 star reviews you will see another variation
Color: 2 ml
click on the Color: 2 ml
that will get
ASIN B013KVZT10 which used to be : Captain Jack’s Comb - Natural Pear Wood Men’s Beard
and under the filters you will see
Showing 1-10 of 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)

Next in the list of the 5 star reviews you will find
Color: d
click on it and you will get to reviews just for the ASIN B00GXFRF8Q
it has
Showing 1-10 of 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)
which is hijacked : 100% Pure Sweet Almond Oil 16oz - Carrier Oil for …

:nauseated_face::nauseated_face::nauseated_face:

keeping a tally so far?
so from what appears to be 2,718 customer reviews
by making variations with inactive products

ASIN B00BV9B3R8 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink)
ASIN B01E1N975K 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
ASIN B01KW6GJR4 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
ASIN B013KVZT10 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)
ASIN B00GXFRF8Q 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)

— so for over 1200 hijacked 5 star reviews from unrelated products

next in 5 star reviews you will find
Color: 1ml 87 reviews(5 star, Color: 1ml) ASIN B00GMOVWQE used to be Samy Fat Hair Amplifying Hair Spray …before AsaVea hijacked it

Color: a 79 reviews(5 star, Color: a ) ASIN B00GMA8BNU Amazon : Organicine Virgin Argan Oil 100% Pure & Organic

…before AsaVea hijacked it

So now we have a seller who hijacked over 1400 5 star reviews just on a single product and can clearly communicate the parent asin and the hijacked asin variations to the seller performance. I checked their other brands and products, this is their Modus Operandi - that is how they roll.

My product was hijacked by them as well - more than one, thus my interest in exposing the fraud and manipulation and helping other sellers who are affected by this type of fraud. The hijacker can overwrite your product any time and then it will take you days or weeks to revert it back, so finding an effective way for everyone to report this so the seller performance folks can clearly understand it and clean up these fraudulent sellers is important to our livelyhood.

90
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

I think they do care, it’s in Amazon’s interest to retain customers, Amazon does not care about retaining the sellers, especially such sellers who break the rules and endanger Amazon’s credibility with customers, once customer loses trust in Amazon… remember Ebay used to be the king and then they let all kinds of scammers rampant on their site and customers moved on…

The key is to be able to communicate effectively with Seller Performance and provide the SP with clear and concise case they can act on, so compiling a nice and neat package for SP, is a step in the right direction

Sending them something like this:


reporting listing violation

Main ASIN B074XDNLWZ

Eyelash Growth Serum for Lash and Brow Irritation by AsaVea

2,718 customer reviews

HIJACKED ASINS that are

ASIN B01E1N975K 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
ASIN B01KW6GJR4 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
ASIN B013KVZT10 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)
ASIN B00GXFRF8Q 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)
ASIN B00GMOVWQE 87 reviews(5 star, Color: 1ml)
ASIN B00GMA8BNU 79 reviews(5 star, Color: a )

joined as a variation under a single parent
out of stock
unrelated products with lots of real verified 5 star reviews
original brand overwritten to AsaVera brand
thus reviews for those products appear under the main asin

We suspect this seller is engaging in co-opting other ASINS
twister-abuse,
variation-abuse,
self-hijacking,
asin-adoption,
shadow-invisible

Please investigate


Trying to come up with a template that would help us all to eradicate this type of fraud,

60
user profile
Seller_92JiJJoiPyBWg

There are actually 3 ways that I know of that these sellers are doing this:

  1. What you said: parent-child relationships.
    However, this is done by more amateur sellers. Only requirement is that firstly, item has been out of stock (permanently) and secondly, to change the brand. Only the brand needs to be changed, not all listing details need to be changed. It’s easier to do and easier for Amazon reps to see the violation, as compared to the other methods. When variations are done, the variations names will appear on top of each customer review. It’s not variations (aka parent-child relationships) if there is no variations names above the reviews.
  2. Co-opting a listing and selling in that listing.
    So basically the seller changed ALL the listing details to sell their product. Hence ASIN A will be changed from productA to productB and seller will still be selling on ASIN A. Seller may also co-opt other listings and either create variations with the other listings or merge as “duplicates”. This does provide some level of blockage against detection because many reps don’t even look at the reviews section when they see a case you created about this. They will simply be like it’s your words against the other seller’s words about what the product details should be. Provide proof that you are right.
  3. The most experienced sellers do this. Create a new listing for the product they want to sell. Co-opt other product listings to this product (basically change all details to this new product). Then merge to their new listing as duplicates. Hence they are selling on the actual product ASIN they created while benefiting from reviews of the other ASINs.
    This allows them to “recycle” successfully co-opted listings of other products. More on this towards the end of the post.
    This method makes it so the more incompetent reps at seller support will not be able to understand what is going on with reviews of other products. Why? The actual ASIN you can see in your address bar is the one the seller created to sell. The other ASINs of other products are not visible, even in search. They have basically been “deleted” when merged this way. Firstly, most reps are familiar with this happening with variations. They are confused when they don’t see variations and see that this ASIN you reported has been selling this product all along, they don’t know what to do, simply try to close case without resolution to move on to the next case they can actually resolve and keep their performance metrics up. Case resolution is that it has been transferred to another team, so this case appears closed. Lies - they don’t know what’s wrong and what team to transfer to. Secondly, remember the “other ASINs” of other products had all their product details changed to this product the seller is selling. So even if you instruct the rep to look at the ASINs merged with the one you are reporting, many of them will see the ASINs are the “same product”, hence “properly merged”. I had a rep on the phone who was this incompetent - I soon realized it’s best I hang up and try again. Thirdly, it seems these sellers try to make little small changes to the listing at a time using several accounts - in order to have a super long change history that will potential make it more difficult for Amazon reps to figure out what’s happening. I was on the phone with a rep for a long time who was telling me how much of the change history he had to load through to be able to find what the original listing was.

Some information I have gathered:
1. These seller accounts that you will find in your search are likely not the ones being used to commit violations.
I have explained this in one or more of the threads linked in the OP’s original post. The more experienced sellers who have been able to do this for a long time likely have several seller accounts.
a) They have “disposable” seller accounts. These accounts do not have any monetary value to the seller, they do not make any sales, they are easily replaceable. They are only used to commit these violations - in case Amazon catches the violation, this account gets taken down, the actual account making sales remains protected. You will not find these “disposable” accounts listing the product for sale at buy-box price.
b) They may have several “monetary” accounts. There may be a few reasons for this. Firstly, it may be because of the low quality products that they sell will have high return rates. High return rates causes Amazon to automatically remove the offer from the particular seller. It can take a couple days to reinstate the offer (after sending a plan of action). Hence when that happens, the other monetary account gets the buy-box and the seller doesn’t lose out on a couple days’ sales. Secondly, for “lightning deals” sales. For lightning deals, Amazon does not allow sellers to price a certain percentage higher that the lowest offer over the past few months. Hence with some of the accounts, they offer a price higher than their “normal” price, but then use those high price offers to still price high enough during a lightning deal. The high-scale “monetary” accounts will usually list the product with FBA.
c) They may have a “scout” account or two. These accounts will basically scout for those listings that are out of stock. Then the scout account will list an offer for those listings. This will usually be a super high-priced offer so that they don’t get the buy-box and also so buyers do not buy from them (since they do have actually have the product in case someone buys from them). They do this to kind of “reserve” the listing for their use. So other sellers who are looking for out of stock listings will not see these “reserved” listings since it’s basically not of out stock anymore. You may see these accounts still with an offer on the listing (since their offer gets transferred over when a merge is done) unless they then changed their inventory count to 0. The reason also for these scout accounts instead of just using the “disposable” accounts for this purpose is firstly, to keep a record of the listings they can use, since the “disposable” accounts will lose all access to the list of listings to be used, and secondly, to keep an offer up on the listings (keep them “reserved”) in case the disposable accounts get taken down. The scout accounts usually do not commit violations.
2. The listings that these sellers have successfully co-opted are often recycled.
The reason these sellers first create a new listing and then merge other listings with the new listing (method #3 of hijacking) is so they can recycle the hijacked listings. Often times these sellers are selling low quality products with a high rate of negative reviews. Usually 1-3 stars if they didn’t do the hijacking. Ofcourse, the aim of the hijacking is to keep reviews around 4.5 to get lots of sales. However, as they sell, real actual reviews of the product start flowing in and after months of selling, their overall ratings reach 4.0 stars or lower. They usually will merge more listings with the product to boost the ratings up. However, the number co-opted listings they have is limited, and they are likely selling lots of products where they need to use such co-opted listings of other products. At a certain point, the ASIN they created by itself has accumulated 100’s of 1-3 stars ratings and it makes better sense to them to abandon the ASIN. Remember the reviews of 1-3 stars are tied to that one ASIN, so they can just abandon it. So what they do is they unmerge the ASINs they had merged. The ASINs they had co-opted of other products will retain their high reviews and ratings. They abandon/close the listing they had previously created (which now has 1-3 stars rating), they create a new listing of the same product, do the merge again and once again start at 4.5 ratings. And keep recycling again and again. If they had simply co-opted ASIN1 and listing an offer on ASIN1, new reviews would be tied to that ASIN. In this case the reviews are tied to the ASINs they create and abandon so they can reuse the other ASINs that they had hijacked. This also creates a lot of changes in the change history of these co-opted listings that creates a lot of work for Amazon reps to be able to figure things out. Also, usually this recycling is done with the same type of product. Say seller is trying to sell pest repellent. They co-opted listing to pest-repellent, then when they abandoned the listing it was merged with, then unmerge, they will usually change some details in the title and pictures in the co-opted listing, and then merge with the new listing - and they do this recycling many times. This shows Amazon reps that there were changes made to the listing but as far as they can see in their change history, it was pest repellent for the most part.


I am compiling a list of sellers to report who are doing this. You may help if you wish. I need the information in the following format:

Brand1

Sellername1
ASIN1
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN2
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN3
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products

Sellername2
ASIN1
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN2
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN3
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products

Let me know if there is a better way to present the information to seller performance.

A lot of the ASINs will have several sellers selling it (usually belonging to the same one seller) although not all of them will have the buy box at a particular time. However they are obviously all in on it. A way to find the ASINs is to go to each of the sellers’ storefront > see products tab. Repeat with each ASIN you find under the tab, ie open ASIN, record it if fraudulent, see sellers selling it, see ASINs being sold by each of those sellers, and repeat. This will give us a HUGE list of ASINs and sellers.

Some other things I’m looking for:

  1. If the same brand has the same (group of) sellers listing under ASINs that have been compromised. It will mean that the seller accounts likely belong to the same one seller. It’s too much coincidence to not be the same seller.
  2. If there a seller account that is on more than one ASIN that has been compromised, it’s obvious it’s not by accident. These are the seller accounts I am looking for.
  3. If the same fraudulent seller account is selling brand1, brand2, it means both brands likely belong to the same seller. Which means that the other brands being sold by seller must also be looked into. If other seller accounts are found selling the other brands, they must also be looked into, it is likely those seller accounts will belong to the same one seller as well.
  4. Remember about the ASINs that sellers eventually abandon and create a new one and reuse co-opted listings? Would be great if we presented a list of those abandoned ASINs. These ASINs will have a history of being merged with the same listings that are merged with the ASINs were are reporting. Also, those ASINs most likely will also have a history of being sold by the same sellers were are reporting. To find these ASINs, simply take the ASINs you found above, copy paste the brand, product name in the search bar > change category dropdown to the category the product is in > search > on the left pane scroll down and check show out of stock. If there are other similar products that were being sold by that brand they will show there. I have found such listings many times. You may find many duplicate products (products that are abandoned).
  5. Also do the above with the scout accounts. You will see many duplicate products under the scout accounts. These are listings that are in the process of having their details changed.
90
user profile
Seller_3R8e0ZEDKX8g5

big news

00
user profile
Seller_Zw8LsZUQSH440

Check B07799VH3X, the dog product turned facial moisturizer. Reported on September 9 and still there.

20
user profile
Seller_ZTRWwBAvMser0

This problem is still rampant even after new review policies :frowning:

Action towards violators are still very slow, which again they just merge it all again.

10
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

I just checked the eyelash serum seller

a few days after we posted this … back in September , their hijacked reviews were disconnected from the product

I was Kudoing Amazon then

now just about all the hijacked reviews are BACK!

10
user profile
Seller_bHyOvNtx4PXTh

how to stop some fraud sellers non-verified purchase review abuse problem?They misuse some thousands such fake reviews everyday,such as : B07NV1NC7T , B07N4K65FD,you will find more such fraud sellers for such products.It seems that Amazon acquiesce in such fake reviews.

10
user profile
Seller_nmZ3PNgBpWo3U

We believe this seller is engaging in fraudulent activity.
New seller, more than 500 listings.

Seller’s name: rulankeji

Link to their storefront:
https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&asin=&isAmazonFulfilled=&isCBA=&marketplaceID=ATVPDKIKX0DER&orderID=&seller=A9HZT97MXZKNS&tab=&vasStoreID=

00
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

1000 plus Hijacked 5 star verified purchase reviews on a single product

Main ASIN B074XDNLWZ
Eyelash Growth Serum for Lash and Brow Irritation by AsaVea

2,718 customer reviews

HIJACKED ASINS that are

  • joined as a variation under a single parent
  • out of stock
  • unrelated products with lots of real verified 5 star reviews
  • original brand overwritten to AsaVera brand
  • thus reviews for those products appear under the main asin

ASIN B00BV9B3R8 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink)
ASIN B01E1N975K 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
ASIN B01KW6GJR4 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
ASIN B013KVZT10 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)
ASIN B00GXFRF8Q 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)
ASIN B00GMOVWQE 87 reviews(5 star, Color: 1ml)
ASIN B00GMA8BNU 79 reviews(5 star, Color: a )

1408 total co-opted 5 Star reviews from unrelated products

We have been hijacked by this brand, more than one of our items so I need to defend and report the violation

Can someone help me determine what are these violations called in the proper terminology so I can give seller performance a proper name for this - besides co-opting a listing it will be one or more of these:

twister-abuse,
variation-abuse,
self-hijacking,
asin-adoption,
shadow-invisible

Thank you in advance!

For those who are experiencing the same issue

I will post ( IN THIS THREAD ) a simple HOW-TO for finding the co-opted ASINs so you can defend your listings efficiently

2.2K views
32 replies
Tags:ASIN, Images, Listing hijack, Listings, SKU
50
Reply
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

1000 plus Hijacked 5 star verified purchase reviews on a single product

Main ASIN B074XDNLWZ
Eyelash Growth Serum for Lash and Brow Irritation by AsaVea

2,718 customer reviews

HIJACKED ASINS that are

  • joined as a variation under a single parent
  • out of stock
  • unrelated products with lots of real verified 5 star reviews
  • original brand overwritten to AsaVera brand
  • thus reviews for those products appear under the main asin

ASIN B00BV9B3R8 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink)
ASIN B01E1N975K 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
ASIN B01KW6GJR4 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
ASIN B013KVZT10 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)
ASIN B00GXFRF8Q 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)
ASIN B00GMOVWQE 87 reviews(5 star, Color: 1ml)
ASIN B00GMA8BNU 79 reviews(5 star, Color: a )

1408 total co-opted 5 Star reviews from unrelated products

We have been hijacked by this brand, more than one of our items so I need to defend and report the violation

Can someone help me determine what are these violations called in the proper terminology so I can give seller performance a proper name for this - besides co-opting a listing it will be one or more of these:

twister-abuse,
variation-abuse,
self-hijacking,
asin-adoption,
shadow-invisible

Thank you in advance!

For those who are experiencing the same issue

I will post ( IN THIS THREAD ) a simple HOW-TO for finding the co-opted ASINs so you can defend your listings efficiently

2.2K views
32 replies
Tags:ASIN, Images, Listing hijack, Listings, SKU
50
Reply
user profile

1000 plus Hijacked 5 star verified purchase reviews on a single product

by Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

Main ASIN B074XDNLWZ
Eyelash Growth Serum for Lash and Brow Irritation by AsaVea

2,718 customer reviews

HIJACKED ASINS that are

  • joined as a variation under a single parent
  • out of stock
  • unrelated products with lots of real verified 5 star reviews
  • original brand overwritten to AsaVera brand
  • thus reviews for those products appear under the main asin

ASIN B00BV9B3R8 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink)
ASIN B01E1N975K 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
ASIN B01KW6GJR4 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
ASIN B013KVZT10 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)
ASIN B00GXFRF8Q 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)
ASIN B00GMOVWQE 87 reviews(5 star, Color: 1ml)
ASIN B00GMA8BNU 79 reviews(5 star, Color: a )

1408 total co-opted 5 Star reviews from unrelated products

We have been hijacked by this brand, more than one of our items so I need to defend and report the violation

Can someone help me determine what are these violations called in the proper terminology so I can give seller performance a proper name for this - besides co-opting a listing it will be one or more of these:

twister-abuse,
variation-abuse,
self-hijacking,
asin-adoption,
shadow-invisible

Thank you in advance!

For those who are experiencing the same issue

I will post ( IN THIS THREAD ) a simple HOW-TO for finding the co-opted ASINs so you can defend your listings efficiently

Tags:ASIN, Images, Listing hijack, Listings, SKU
50
2.2K views
32 replies
Reply
32 replies
32 replies
Quick filters
Sort by
user profile
Seller_Zw8LsZUQSH440

Amazon has no interest in stopping this practice. Violation reports are ignored and both customers and sellers are ripped off. Not to mention the fact that these cosmetics products may be dangerous.

20
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

Here is a simple how-to find hijacked unrelated ASINS when a seller co-opted your listings and changed images, brand, title to hijack your product reviews

for example


look at ASIN B074XDNLWZ
Eyelash Growth Serum for Lash and Brow Irritation by AsaVea
2,718 customer reviews
wow that’s a lot of reviews

MOST IMPORTANT STEP 1

click on the 5 star reviews


scroll down to the actual reviews and right before VERIFIED PURCHASE you will see if the review is for variation X or variation Y etc…

this one has the following variations
COLOR: 3 ML
Reading those reviews, they are for eyelash growth serum those are the real reviews that belong to the hijacker’s ASIN- so skip over those and
keep on scrolling down THOSE 5 STAR REVIEWS till you see a review for another variation
Evantually on page 2 of the 5 star reviews you will see a review for
Variation ----> Color: Cute Pink

STEP 2

so click on the Color: Cute Pink - IT IS A LINK AND IT WILL SEGREGATE JUST THE REVIEWS FOR VARIATION COLOR CUTE PINK
THEN IN THE WEB address IT WILL SHOW YOU THE ASIN NUMBER OF THAT VARIATION
SO COLOR CUTE PINK IS ASIN B00BV9B3R8
Now we will see the reviews just for that variation only ( if you clicked on the Color: Cute Pink link in the reviews )


Scroll down under the filter buttons on that review page, you will see
Showing 1-10 of 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink).

… and all the reviews that are for the Amazon Fire case, i-UniK Amazon Fire 7" Display Wi-Fi which was hijacked by AsaVea and subsequently they changed the CUTE PINK FIRE CASE to Peel Off Mask and AsaVea brand and joined it as a ghost variation to their EYELASH product

STEP 3

Record the Hijacked ASIN from the web address of the reviews, in this case it is
ASIN B00BV9B3R8
Record number of hijacked reviews 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink).

RINSE AND REPEAT STEP 1 THROUGH 3 TILL YOU HAVE ENOUGH ASINS THAT WERE HIJACKED TO SUBMIT YOUR REPORT

… go back to all 5 star reviews


keep going to page 2 or 3 till you see

next variation is
Color: e
Click on that color e
that will get you to this page
which is for ASIN B01E1N975K
and under the sort buttons you will see
Showing 1-10 of 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
and all those reviews are for nail clippers ASIN B01E1N975K

NEXT YOU MAY WANT TO RUN THAT ASIN B01E1N975K THROUGH GOOGLE AND YOU WILL SEE THAT ASIN USED TO BE
google cache for asin B01E1N975K
Nail Clipper Set with Nail File and Buffer, Fingernail and Toenail Clippers by Sensible Needs - Nail Cutters - Manicure Set

then we can step over back to ALL 5star reveiws
and find the next variation
now we have
Color: Amber
click on Color Amber and you will get reviews for the Color: Amber
you will get
so this one is ASIN B01KW6GJR4
Showing 1-10 of 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
That ASIN used to be: Pure Organic Jojoba Oil (2 Oz.) Best Quality Oil For

Next going back to all 5 star reviews you will see another variation
Color: 2 ml
click on the Color: 2 ml
that will get
ASIN B013KVZT10 which used to be : Captain Jack’s Comb - Natural Pear Wood Men’s Beard
and under the filters you will see
Showing 1-10 of 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)

Next in the list of the 5 star reviews you will find
Color: d
click on it and you will get to reviews just for the ASIN B00GXFRF8Q
it has
Showing 1-10 of 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)
which is hijacked : 100% Pure Sweet Almond Oil 16oz - Carrier Oil for …

:nauseated_face::nauseated_face::nauseated_face:

keeping a tally so far?
so from what appears to be 2,718 customer reviews
by making variations with inactive products

ASIN B00BV9B3R8 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink)
ASIN B01E1N975K 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
ASIN B01KW6GJR4 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
ASIN B013KVZT10 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)
ASIN B00GXFRF8Q 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)

— so for over 1200 hijacked 5 star reviews from unrelated products

next in 5 star reviews you will find
Color: 1ml 87 reviews(5 star, Color: 1ml) ASIN B00GMOVWQE used to be Samy Fat Hair Amplifying Hair Spray …before AsaVea hijacked it

Color: a 79 reviews(5 star, Color: a ) ASIN B00GMA8BNU Amazon : Organicine Virgin Argan Oil 100% Pure & Organic

…before AsaVea hijacked it

So now we have a seller who hijacked over 1400 5 star reviews just on a single product and can clearly communicate the parent asin and the hijacked asin variations to the seller performance. I checked their other brands and products, this is their Modus Operandi - that is how they roll.

My product was hijacked by them as well - more than one, thus my interest in exposing the fraud and manipulation and helping other sellers who are affected by this type of fraud. The hijacker can overwrite your product any time and then it will take you days or weeks to revert it back, so finding an effective way for everyone to report this so the seller performance folks can clearly understand it and clean up these fraudulent sellers is important to our livelyhood.

90
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

I think they do care, it’s in Amazon’s interest to retain customers, Amazon does not care about retaining the sellers, especially such sellers who break the rules and endanger Amazon’s credibility with customers, once customer loses trust in Amazon… remember Ebay used to be the king and then they let all kinds of scammers rampant on their site and customers moved on…

The key is to be able to communicate effectively with Seller Performance and provide the SP with clear and concise case they can act on, so compiling a nice and neat package for SP, is a step in the right direction

Sending them something like this:


reporting listing violation

Main ASIN B074XDNLWZ

Eyelash Growth Serum for Lash and Brow Irritation by AsaVea

2,718 customer reviews

HIJACKED ASINS that are

ASIN B01E1N975K 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
ASIN B01KW6GJR4 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
ASIN B013KVZT10 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)
ASIN B00GXFRF8Q 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)
ASIN B00GMOVWQE 87 reviews(5 star, Color: 1ml)
ASIN B00GMA8BNU 79 reviews(5 star, Color: a )

joined as a variation under a single parent
out of stock
unrelated products with lots of real verified 5 star reviews
original brand overwritten to AsaVera brand
thus reviews for those products appear under the main asin

We suspect this seller is engaging in co-opting other ASINS
twister-abuse,
variation-abuse,
self-hijacking,
asin-adoption,
shadow-invisible

Please investigate


Trying to come up with a template that would help us all to eradicate this type of fraud,

60
user profile
Seller_92JiJJoiPyBWg

There are actually 3 ways that I know of that these sellers are doing this:

  1. What you said: parent-child relationships.
    However, this is done by more amateur sellers. Only requirement is that firstly, item has been out of stock (permanently) and secondly, to change the brand. Only the brand needs to be changed, not all listing details need to be changed. It’s easier to do and easier for Amazon reps to see the violation, as compared to the other methods. When variations are done, the variations names will appear on top of each customer review. It’s not variations (aka parent-child relationships) if there is no variations names above the reviews.
  2. Co-opting a listing and selling in that listing.
    So basically the seller changed ALL the listing details to sell their product. Hence ASIN A will be changed from productA to productB and seller will still be selling on ASIN A. Seller may also co-opt other listings and either create variations with the other listings or merge as “duplicates”. This does provide some level of blockage against detection because many reps don’t even look at the reviews section when they see a case you created about this. They will simply be like it’s your words against the other seller’s words about what the product details should be. Provide proof that you are right.
  3. The most experienced sellers do this. Create a new listing for the product they want to sell. Co-opt other product listings to this product (basically change all details to this new product). Then merge to their new listing as duplicates. Hence they are selling on the actual product ASIN they created while benefiting from reviews of the other ASINs.
    This allows them to “recycle” successfully co-opted listings of other products. More on this towards the end of the post.
    This method makes it so the more incompetent reps at seller support will not be able to understand what is going on with reviews of other products. Why? The actual ASIN you can see in your address bar is the one the seller created to sell. The other ASINs of other products are not visible, even in search. They have basically been “deleted” when merged this way. Firstly, most reps are familiar with this happening with variations. They are confused when they don’t see variations and see that this ASIN you reported has been selling this product all along, they don’t know what to do, simply try to close case without resolution to move on to the next case they can actually resolve and keep their performance metrics up. Case resolution is that it has been transferred to another team, so this case appears closed. Lies - they don’t know what’s wrong and what team to transfer to. Secondly, remember the “other ASINs” of other products had all their product details changed to this product the seller is selling. So even if you instruct the rep to look at the ASINs merged with the one you are reporting, many of them will see the ASINs are the “same product”, hence “properly merged”. I had a rep on the phone who was this incompetent - I soon realized it’s best I hang up and try again. Thirdly, it seems these sellers try to make little small changes to the listing at a time using several accounts - in order to have a super long change history that will potential make it more difficult for Amazon reps to figure out what’s happening. I was on the phone with a rep for a long time who was telling me how much of the change history he had to load through to be able to find what the original listing was.

Some information I have gathered:
1. These seller accounts that you will find in your search are likely not the ones being used to commit violations.
I have explained this in one or more of the threads linked in the OP’s original post. The more experienced sellers who have been able to do this for a long time likely have several seller accounts.
a) They have “disposable” seller accounts. These accounts do not have any monetary value to the seller, they do not make any sales, they are easily replaceable. They are only used to commit these violations - in case Amazon catches the violation, this account gets taken down, the actual account making sales remains protected. You will not find these “disposable” accounts listing the product for sale at buy-box price.
b) They may have several “monetary” accounts. There may be a few reasons for this. Firstly, it may be because of the low quality products that they sell will have high return rates. High return rates causes Amazon to automatically remove the offer from the particular seller. It can take a couple days to reinstate the offer (after sending a plan of action). Hence when that happens, the other monetary account gets the buy-box and the seller doesn’t lose out on a couple days’ sales. Secondly, for “lightning deals” sales. For lightning deals, Amazon does not allow sellers to price a certain percentage higher that the lowest offer over the past few months. Hence with some of the accounts, they offer a price higher than their “normal” price, but then use those high price offers to still price high enough during a lightning deal. The high-scale “monetary” accounts will usually list the product with FBA.
c) They may have a “scout” account or two. These accounts will basically scout for those listings that are out of stock. Then the scout account will list an offer for those listings. This will usually be a super high-priced offer so that they don’t get the buy-box and also so buyers do not buy from them (since they do have actually have the product in case someone buys from them). They do this to kind of “reserve” the listing for their use. So other sellers who are looking for out of stock listings will not see these “reserved” listings since it’s basically not of out stock anymore. You may see these accounts still with an offer on the listing (since their offer gets transferred over when a merge is done) unless they then changed their inventory count to 0. The reason also for these scout accounts instead of just using the “disposable” accounts for this purpose is firstly, to keep a record of the listings they can use, since the “disposable” accounts will lose all access to the list of listings to be used, and secondly, to keep an offer up on the listings (keep them “reserved”) in case the disposable accounts get taken down. The scout accounts usually do not commit violations.
2. The listings that these sellers have successfully co-opted are often recycled.
The reason these sellers first create a new listing and then merge other listings with the new listing (method #3 of hijacking) is so they can recycle the hijacked listings. Often times these sellers are selling low quality products with a high rate of negative reviews. Usually 1-3 stars if they didn’t do the hijacking. Ofcourse, the aim of the hijacking is to keep reviews around 4.5 to get lots of sales. However, as they sell, real actual reviews of the product start flowing in and after months of selling, their overall ratings reach 4.0 stars or lower. They usually will merge more listings with the product to boost the ratings up. However, the number co-opted listings they have is limited, and they are likely selling lots of products where they need to use such co-opted listings of other products. At a certain point, the ASIN they created by itself has accumulated 100’s of 1-3 stars ratings and it makes better sense to them to abandon the ASIN. Remember the reviews of 1-3 stars are tied to that one ASIN, so they can just abandon it. So what they do is they unmerge the ASINs they had merged. The ASINs they had co-opted of other products will retain their high reviews and ratings. They abandon/close the listing they had previously created (which now has 1-3 stars rating), they create a new listing of the same product, do the merge again and once again start at 4.5 ratings. And keep recycling again and again. If they had simply co-opted ASIN1 and listing an offer on ASIN1, new reviews would be tied to that ASIN. In this case the reviews are tied to the ASINs they create and abandon so they can reuse the other ASINs that they had hijacked. This also creates a lot of changes in the change history of these co-opted listings that creates a lot of work for Amazon reps to be able to figure things out. Also, usually this recycling is done with the same type of product. Say seller is trying to sell pest repellent. They co-opted listing to pest-repellent, then when they abandoned the listing it was merged with, then unmerge, they will usually change some details in the title and pictures in the co-opted listing, and then merge with the new listing - and they do this recycling many times. This shows Amazon reps that there were changes made to the listing but as far as they can see in their change history, it was pest repellent for the most part.


I am compiling a list of sellers to report who are doing this. You may help if you wish. I need the information in the following format:

Brand1

Sellername1
ASIN1
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN2
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN3
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products

Sellername2
ASIN1
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN2
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN3
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products

Let me know if there is a better way to present the information to seller performance.

A lot of the ASINs will have several sellers selling it (usually belonging to the same one seller) although not all of them will have the buy box at a particular time. However they are obviously all in on it. A way to find the ASINs is to go to each of the sellers’ storefront > see products tab. Repeat with each ASIN you find under the tab, ie open ASIN, record it if fraudulent, see sellers selling it, see ASINs being sold by each of those sellers, and repeat. This will give us a HUGE list of ASINs and sellers.

Some other things I’m looking for:

  1. If the same brand has the same (group of) sellers listing under ASINs that have been compromised. It will mean that the seller accounts likely belong to the same one seller. It’s too much coincidence to not be the same seller.
  2. If there a seller account that is on more than one ASIN that has been compromised, it’s obvious it’s not by accident. These are the seller accounts I am looking for.
  3. If the same fraudulent seller account is selling brand1, brand2, it means both brands likely belong to the same seller. Which means that the other brands being sold by seller must also be looked into. If other seller accounts are found selling the other brands, they must also be looked into, it is likely those seller accounts will belong to the same one seller as well.
  4. Remember about the ASINs that sellers eventually abandon and create a new one and reuse co-opted listings? Would be great if we presented a list of those abandoned ASINs. These ASINs will have a history of being merged with the same listings that are merged with the ASINs were are reporting. Also, those ASINs most likely will also have a history of being sold by the same sellers were are reporting. To find these ASINs, simply take the ASINs you found above, copy paste the brand, product name in the search bar > change category dropdown to the category the product is in > search > on the left pane scroll down and check show out of stock. If there are other similar products that were being sold by that brand they will show there. I have found such listings many times. You may find many duplicate products (products that are abandoned).
  5. Also do the above with the scout accounts. You will see many duplicate products under the scout accounts. These are listings that are in the process of having their details changed.
90
user profile
Seller_3R8e0ZEDKX8g5

big news

00
user profile
Seller_Zw8LsZUQSH440

Check B07799VH3X, the dog product turned facial moisturizer. Reported on September 9 and still there.

20
user profile
Seller_ZTRWwBAvMser0

This problem is still rampant even after new review policies :frowning:

Action towards violators are still very slow, which again they just merge it all again.

10
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

I just checked the eyelash serum seller

a few days after we posted this … back in September , their hijacked reviews were disconnected from the product

I was Kudoing Amazon then

now just about all the hijacked reviews are BACK!

10
user profile
Seller_bHyOvNtx4PXTh

how to stop some fraud sellers non-verified purchase review abuse problem?They misuse some thousands such fake reviews everyday,such as : B07NV1NC7T , B07N4K65FD,you will find more such fraud sellers for such products.It seems that Amazon acquiesce in such fake reviews.

10
user profile
Seller_nmZ3PNgBpWo3U

We believe this seller is engaging in fraudulent activity.
New seller, more than 500 listings.

Seller’s name: rulankeji

Link to their storefront:
https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&asin=&isAmazonFulfilled=&isCBA=&marketplaceID=ATVPDKIKX0DER&orderID=&seller=A9HZT97MXZKNS&tab=&vasStoreID=

00
user profile
Seller_Zw8LsZUQSH440

Amazon has no interest in stopping this practice. Violation reports are ignored and both customers and sellers are ripped off. Not to mention the fact that these cosmetics products may be dangerous.

20
user profile
Seller_Zw8LsZUQSH440

Amazon has no interest in stopping this practice. Violation reports are ignored and both customers and sellers are ripped off. Not to mention the fact that these cosmetics products may be dangerous.

20
Reply
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

Here is a simple how-to find hijacked unrelated ASINS when a seller co-opted your listings and changed images, brand, title to hijack your product reviews

for example


look at ASIN B074XDNLWZ
Eyelash Growth Serum for Lash and Brow Irritation by AsaVea
2,718 customer reviews
wow that’s a lot of reviews

MOST IMPORTANT STEP 1

click on the 5 star reviews


scroll down to the actual reviews and right before VERIFIED PURCHASE you will see if the review is for variation X or variation Y etc…

this one has the following variations
COLOR: 3 ML
Reading those reviews, they are for eyelash growth serum those are the real reviews that belong to the hijacker’s ASIN- so skip over those and
keep on scrolling down THOSE 5 STAR REVIEWS till you see a review for another variation
Evantually on page 2 of the 5 star reviews you will see a review for
Variation ----> Color: Cute Pink

STEP 2

so click on the Color: Cute Pink - IT IS A LINK AND IT WILL SEGREGATE JUST THE REVIEWS FOR VARIATION COLOR CUTE PINK
THEN IN THE WEB address IT WILL SHOW YOU THE ASIN NUMBER OF THAT VARIATION
SO COLOR CUTE PINK IS ASIN B00BV9B3R8
Now we will see the reviews just for that variation only ( if you clicked on the Color: Cute Pink link in the reviews )


Scroll down under the filter buttons on that review page, you will see
Showing 1-10 of 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink).

… and all the reviews that are for the Amazon Fire case, i-UniK Amazon Fire 7" Display Wi-Fi which was hijacked by AsaVea and subsequently they changed the CUTE PINK FIRE CASE to Peel Off Mask and AsaVea brand and joined it as a ghost variation to their EYELASH product

STEP 3

Record the Hijacked ASIN from the web address of the reviews, in this case it is
ASIN B00BV9B3R8
Record number of hijacked reviews 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink).

RINSE AND REPEAT STEP 1 THROUGH 3 TILL YOU HAVE ENOUGH ASINS THAT WERE HIJACKED TO SUBMIT YOUR REPORT

… go back to all 5 star reviews


keep going to page 2 or 3 till you see

next variation is
Color: e
Click on that color e
that will get you to this page
which is for ASIN B01E1N975K
and under the sort buttons you will see
Showing 1-10 of 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
and all those reviews are for nail clippers ASIN B01E1N975K

NEXT YOU MAY WANT TO RUN THAT ASIN B01E1N975K THROUGH GOOGLE AND YOU WILL SEE THAT ASIN USED TO BE
google cache for asin B01E1N975K
Nail Clipper Set with Nail File and Buffer, Fingernail and Toenail Clippers by Sensible Needs - Nail Cutters - Manicure Set

then we can step over back to ALL 5star reveiws
and find the next variation
now we have
Color: Amber
click on Color Amber and you will get reviews for the Color: Amber
you will get
so this one is ASIN B01KW6GJR4
Showing 1-10 of 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
That ASIN used to be: Pure Organic Jojoba Oil (2 Oz.) Best Quality Oil For

Next going back to all 5 star reviews you will see another variation
Color: 2 ml
click on the Color: 2 ml
that will get
ASIN B013KVZT10 which used to be : Captain Jack’s Comb - Natural Pear Wood Men’s Beard
and under the filters you will see
Showing 1-10 of 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)

Next in the list of the 5 star reviews you will find
Color: d
click on it and you will get to reviews just for the ASIN B00GXFRF8Q
it has
Showing 1-10 of 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)
which is hijacked : 100% Pure Sweet Almond Oil 16oz - Carrier Oil for …

:nauseated_face::nauseated_face::nauseated_face:

keeping a tally so far?
so from what appears to be 2,718 customer reviews
by making variations with inactive products

ASIN B00BV9B3R8 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink)
ASIN B01E1N975K 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
ASIN B01KW6GJR4 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
ASIN B013KVZT10 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)
ASIN B00GXFRF8Q 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)

— so for over 1200 hijacked 5 star reviews from unrelated products

next in 5 star reviews you will find
Color: 1ml 87 reviews(5 star, Color: 1ml) ASIN B00GMOVWQE used to be Samy Fat Hair Amplifying Hair Spray …before AsaVea hijacked it

Color: a 79 reviews(5 star, Color: a ) ASIN B00GMA8BNU Amazon : Organicine Virgin Argan Oil 100% Pure & Organic

…before AsaVea hijacked it

So now we have a seller who hijacked over 1400 5 star reviews just on a single product and can clearly communicate the parent asin and the hijacked asin variations to the seller performance. I checked their other brands and products, this is their Modus Operandi - that is how they roll.

My product was hijacked by them as well - more than one, thus my interest in exposing the fraud and manipulation and helping other sellers who are affected by this type of fraud. The hijacker can overwrite your product any time and then it will take you days or weeks to revert it back, so finding an effective way for everyone to report this so the seller performance folks can clearly understand it and clean up these fraudulent sellers is important to our livelyhood.

90
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

Here is a simple how-to find hijacked unrelated ASINS when a seller co-opted your listings and changed images, brand, title to hijack your product reviews

for example


look at ASIN B074XDNLWZ
Eyelash Growth Serum for Lash and Brow Irritation by AsaVea
2,718 customer reviews
wow that’s a lot of reviews

MOST IMPORTANT STEP 1

click on the 5 star reviews


scroll down to the actual reviews and right before VERIFIED PURCHASE you will see if the review is for variation X or variation Y etc…

this one has the following variations
COLOR: 3 ML
Reading those reviews, they are for eyelash growth serum those are the real reviews that belong to the hijacker’s ASIN- so skip over those and
keep on scrolling down THOSE 5 STAR REVIEWS till you see a review for another variation
Evantually on page 2 of the 5 star reviews you will see a review for
Variation ----> Color: Cute Pink

STEP 2

so click on the Color: Cute Pink - IT IS A LINK AND IT WILL SEGREGATE JUST THE REVIEWS FOR VARIATION COLOR CUTE PINK
THEN IN THE WEB address IT WILL SHOW YOU THE ASIN NUMBER OF THAT VARIATION
SO COLOR CUTE PINK IS ASIN B00BV9B3R8
Now we will see the reviews just for that variation only ( if you clicked on the Color: Cute Pink link in the reviews )


Scroll down under the filter buttons on that review page, you will see
Showing 1-10 of 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink).

… and all the reviews that are for the Amazon Fire case, i-UniK Amazon Fire 7" Display Wi-Fi which was hijacked by AsaVea and subsequently they changed the CUTE PINK FIRE CASE to Peel Off Mask and AsaVea brand and joined it as a ghost variation to their EYELASH product

STEP 3

Record the Hijacked ASIN from the web address of the reviews, in this case it is
ASIN B00BV9B3R8
Record number of hijacked reviews 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink).

RINSE AND REPEAT STEP 1 THROUGH 3 TILL YOU HAVE ENOUGH ASINS THAT WERE HIJACKED TO SUBMIT YOUR REPORT

… go back to all 5 star reviews


keep going to page 2 or 3 till you see

next variation is
Color: e
Click on that color e
that will get you to this page
which is for ASIN B01E1N975K
and under the sort buttons you will see
Showing 1-10 of 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
and all those reviews are for nail clippers ASIN B01E1N975K

NEXT YOU MAY WANT TO RUN THAT ASIN B01E1N975K THROUGH GOOGLE AND YOU WILL SEE THAT ASIN USED TO BE
google cache for asin B01E1N975K
Nail Clipper Set with Nail File and Buffer, Fingernail and Toenail Clippers by Sensible Needs - Nail Cutters - Manicure Set

then we can step over back to ALL 5star reveiws
and find the next variation
now we have
Color: Amber
click on Color Amber and you will get reviews for the Color: Amber
you will get
so this one is ASIN B01KW6GJR4
Showing 1-10 of 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
That ASIN used to be: Pure Organic Jojoba Oil (2 Oz.) Best Quality Oil For

Next going back to all 5 star reviews you will see another variation
Color: 2 ml
click on the Color: 2 ml
that will get
ASIN B013KVZT10 which used to be : Captain Jack’s Comb - Natural Pear Wood Men’s Beard
and under the filters you will see
Showing 1-10 of 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)

Next in the list of the 5 star reviews you will find
Color: d
click on it and you will get to reviews just for the ASIN B00GXFRF8Q
it has
Showing 1-10 of 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)
which is hijacked : 100% Pure Sweet Almond Oil 16oz - Carrier Oil for …

:nauseated_face::nauseated_face::nauseated_face:

keeping a tally so far?
so from what appears to be 2,718 customer reviews
by making variations with inactive products

ASIN B00BV9B3R8 314 reviews(5 star, Color: Cute Pink)
ASIN B01E1N975K 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
ASIN B01KW6GJR4 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
ASIN B013KVZT10 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)
ASIN B00GXFRF8Q 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)

— so for over 1200 hijacked 5 star reviews from unrelated products

next in 5 star reviews you will find
Color: 1ml 87 reviews(5 star, Color: 1ml) ASIN B00GMOVWQE used to be Samy Fat Hair Amplifying Hair Spray …before AsaVea hijacked it

Color: a 79 reviews(5 star, Color: a ) ASIN B00GMA8BNU Amazon : Organicine Virgin Argan Oil 100% Pure & Organic

…before AsaVea hijacked it

So now we have a seller who hijacked over 1400 5 star reviews just on a single product and can clearly communicate the parent asin and the hijacked asin variations to the seller performance. I checked their other brands and products, this is their Modus Operandi - that is how they roll.

My product was hijacked by them as well - more than one, thus my interest in exposing the fraud and manipulation and helping other sellers who are affected by this type of fraud. The hijacker can overwrite your product any time and then it will take you days or weeks to revert it back, so finding an effective way for everyone to report this so the seller performance folks can clearly understand it and clean up these fraudulent sellers is important to our livelyhood.

90
Reply
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

I think they do care, it’s in Amazon’s interest to retain customers, Amazon does not care about retaining the sellers, especially such sellers who break the rules and endanger Amazon’s credibility with customers, once customer loses trust in Amazon… remember Ebay used to be the king and then they let all kinds of scammers rampant on their site and customers moved on…

The key is to be able to communicate effectively with Seller Performance and provide the SP with clear and concise case they can act on, so compiling a nice and neat package for SP, is a step in the right direction

Sending them something like this:


reporting listing violation

Main ASIN B074XDNLWZ

Eyelash Growth Serum for Lash and Brow Irritation by AsaVea

2,718 customer reviews

HIJACKED ASINS that are

ASIN B01E1N975K 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
ASIN B01KW6GJR4 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
ASIN B013KVZT10 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)
ASIN B00GXFRF8Q 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)
ASIN B00GMOVWQE 87 reviews(5 star, Color: 1ml)
ASIN B00GMA8BNU 79 reviews(5 star, Color: a )

joined as a variation under a single parent
out of stock
unrelated products with lots of real verified 5 star reviews
original brand overwritten to AsaVera brand
thus reviews for those products appear under the main asin

We suspect this seller is engaging in co-opting other ASINS
twister-abuse,
variation-abuse,
self-hijacking,
asin-adoption,
shadow-invisible

Please investigate


Trying to come up with a template that would help us all to eradicate this type of fraud,

60
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

I think they do care, it’s in Amazon’s interest to retain customers, Amazon does not care about retaining the sellers, especially such sellers who break the rules and endanger Amazon’s credibility with customers, once customer loses trust in Amazon… remember Ebay used to be the king and then they let all kinds of scammers rampant on their site and customers moved on…

The key is to be able to communicate effectively with Seller Performance and provide the SP with clear and concise case they can act on, so compiling a nice and neat package for SP, is a step in the right direction

Sending them something like this:


reporting listing violation

Main ASIN B074XDNLWZ

Eyelash Growth Serum for Lash and Brow Irritation by AsaVea

2,718 customer reviews

HIJACKED ASINS that are

ASIN B01E1N975K 409 reviews(5 star, Color: e)
ASIN B01KW6GJR4 221 reviews(5 star, Color: Amber).
ASIN B013KVZT10 207 reviews(5 star, Color: 2 ml)
ASIN B00GXFRF8Q 91 reviews(5 star, Color: d)
ASIN B00GMOVWQE 87 reviews(5 star, Color: 1ml)
ASIN B00GMA8BNU 79 reviews(5 star, Color: a )

joined as a variation under a single parent
out of stock
unrelated products with lots of real verified 5 star reviews
original brand overwritten to AsaVera brand
thus reviews for those products appear under the main asin

We suspect this seller is engaging in co-opting other ASINS
twister-abuse,
variation-abuse,
self-hijacking,
asin-adoption,
shadow-invisible

Please investigate


Trying to come up with a template that would help us all to eradicate this type of fraud,

60
Reply
user profile
Seller_92JiJJoiPyBWg

There are actually 3 ways that I know of that these sellers are doing this:

  1. What you said: parent-child relationships.
    However, this is done by more amateur sellers. Only requirement is that firstly, item has been out of stock (permanently) and secondly, to change the brand. Only the brand needs to be changed, not all listing details need to be changed. It’s easier to do and easier for Amazon reps to see the violation, as compared to the other methods. When variations are done, the variations names will appear on top of each customer review. It’s not variations (aka parent-child relationships) if there is no variations names above the reviews.
  2. Co-opting a listing and selling in that listing.
    So basically the seller changed ALL the listing details to sell their product. Hence ASIN A will be changed from productA to productB and seller will still be selling on ASIN A. Seller may also co-opt other listings and either create variations with the other listings or merge as “duplicates”. This does provide some level of blockage against detection because many reps don’t even look at the reviews section when they see a case you created about this. They will simply be like it’s your words against the other seller’s words about what the product details should be. Provide proof that you are right.
  3. The most experienced sellers do this. Create a new listing for the product they want to sell. Co-opt other product listings to this product (basically change all details to this new product). Then merge to their new listing as duplicates. Hence they are selling on the actual product ASIN they created while benefiting from reviews of the other ASINs.
    This allows them to “recycle” successfully co-opted listings of other products. More on this towards the end of the post.
    This method makes it so the more incompetent reps at seller support will not be able to understand what is going on with reviews of other products. Why? The actual ASIN you can see in your address bar is the one the seller created to sell. The other ASINs of other products are not visible, even in search. They have basically been “deleted” when merged this way. Firstly, most reps are familiar with this happening with variations. They are confused when they don’t see variations and see that this ASIN you reported has been selling this product all along, they don’t know what to do, simply try to close case without resolution to move on to the next case they can actually resolve and keep their performance metrics up. Case resolution is that it has been transferred to another team, so this case appears closed. Lies - they don’t know what’s wrong and what team to transfer to. Secondly, remember the “other ASINs” of other products had all their product details changed to this product the seller is selling. So even if you instruct the rep to look at the ASINs merged with the one you are reporting, many of them will see the ASINs are the “same product”, hence “properly merged”. I had a rep on the phone who was this incompetent - I soon realized it’s best I hang up and try again. Thirdly, it seems these sellers try to make little small changes to the listing at a time using several accounts - in order to have a super long change history that will potential make it more difficult for Amazon reps to figure out what’s happening. I was on the phone with a rep for a long time who was telling me how much of the change history he had to load through to be able to find what the original listing was.

Some information I have gathered:
1. These seller accounts that you will find in your search are likely not the ones being used to commit violations.
I have explained this in one or more of the threads linked in the OP’s original post. The more experienced sellers who have been able to do this for a long time likely have several seller accounts.
a) They have “disposable” seller accounts. These accounts do not have any monetary value to the seller, they do not make any sales, they are easily replaceable. They are only used to commit these violations - in case Amazon catches the violation, this account gets taken down, the actual account making sales remains protected. You will not find these “disposable” accounts listing the product for sale at buy-box price.
b) They may have several “monetary” accounts. There may be a few reasons for this. Firstly, it may be because of the low quality products that they sell will have high return rates. High return rates causes Amazon to automatically remove the offer from the particular seller. It can take a couple days to reinstate the offer (after sending a plan of action). Hence when that happens, the other monetary account gets the buy-box and the seller doesn’t lose out on a couple days’ sales. Secondly, for “lightning deals” sales. For lightning deals, Amazon does not allow sellers to price a certain percentage higher that the lowest offer over the past few months. Hence with some of the accounts, they offer a price higher than their “normal” price, but then use those high price offers to still price high enough during a lightning deal. The high-scale “monetary” accounts will usually list the product with FBA.
c) They may have a “scout” account or two. These accounts will basically scout for those listings that are out of stock. Then the scout account will list an offer for those listings. This will usually be a super high-priced offer so that they don’t get the buy-box and also so buyers do not buy from them (since they do have actually have the product in case someone buys from them). They do this to kind of “reserve” the listing for their use. So other sellers who are looking for out of stock listings will not see these “reserved” listings since it’s basically not of out stock anymore. You may see these accounts still with an offer on the listing (since their offer gets transferred over when a merge is done) unless they then changed their inventory count to 0. The reason also for these scout accounts instead of just using the “disposable” accounts for this purpose is firstly, to keep a record of the listings they can use, since the “disposable” accounts will lose all access to the list of listings to be used, and secondly, to keep an offer up on the listings (keep them “reserved”) in case the disposable accounts get taken down. The scout accounts usually do not commit violations.
2. The listings that these sellers have successfully co-opted are often recycled.
The reason these sellers first create a new listing and then merge other listings with the new listing (method #3 of hijacking) is so they can recycle the hijacked listings. Often times these sellers are selling low quality products with a high rate of negative reviews. Usually 1-3 stars if they didn’t do the hijacking. Ofcourse, the aim of the hijacking is to keep reviews around 4.5 to get lots of sales. However, as they sell, real actual reviews of the product start flowing in and after months of selling, their overall ratings reach 4.0 stars or lower. They usually will merge more listings with the product to boost the ratings up. However, the number co-opted listings they have is limited, and they are likely selling lots of products where they need to use such co-opted listings of other products. At a certain point, the ASIN they created by itself has accumulated 100’s of 1-3 stars ratings and it makes better sense to them to abandon the ASIN. Remember the reviews of 1-3 stars are tied to that one ASIN, so they can just abandon it. So what they do is they unmerge the ASINs they had merged. The ASINs they had co-opted of other products will retain their high reviews and ratings. They abandon/close the listing they had previously created (which now has 1-3 stars rating), they create a new listing of the same product, do the merge again and once again start at 4.5 ratings. And keep recycling again and again. If they had simply co-opted ASIN1 and listing an offer on ASIN1, new reviews would be tied to that ASIN. In this case the reviews are tied to the ASINs they create and abandon so they can reuse the other ASINs that they had hijacked. This also creates a lot of changes in the change history of these co-opted listings that creates a lot of work for Amazon reps to be able to figure things out. Also, usually this recycling is done with the same type of product. Say seller is trying to sell pest repellent. They co-opted listing to pest-repellent, then when they abandoned the listing it was merged with, then unmerge, they will usually change some details in the title and pictures in the co-opted listing, and then merge with the new listing - and they do this recycling many times. This shows Amazon reps that there were changes made to the listing but as far as they can see in their change history, it was pest repellent for the most part.


I am compiling a list of sellers to report who are doing this. You may help if you wish. I need the information in the following format:

Brand1

Sellername1
ASIN1
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN2
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN3
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products

Sellername2
ASIN1
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN2
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN3
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products

Let me know if there is a better way to present the information to seller performance.

A lot of the ASINs will have several sellers selling it (usually belonging to the same one seller) although not all of them will have the buy box at a particular time. However they are obviously all in on it. A way to find the ASINs is to go to each of the sellers’ storefront > see products tab. Repeat with each ASIN you find under the tab, ie open ASIN, record it if fraudulent, see sellers selling it, see ASINs being sold by each of those sellers, and repeat. This will give us a HUGE list of ASINs and sellers.

Some other things I’m looking for:

  1. If the same brand has the same (group of) sellers listing under ASINs that have been compromised. It will mean that the seller accounts likely belong to the same one seller. It’s too much coincidence to not be the same seller.
  2. If there a seller account that is on more than one ASIN that has been compromised, it’s obvious it’s not by accident. These are the seller accounts I am looking for.
  3. If the same fraudulent seller account is selling brand1, brand2, it means both brands likely belong to the same seller. Which means that the other brands being sold by seller must also be looked into. If other seller accounts are found selling the other brands, they must also be looked into, it is likely those seller accounts will belong to the same one seller as well.
  4. Remember about the ASINs that sellers eventually abandon and create a new one and reuse co-opted listings? Would be great if we presented a list of those abandoned ASINs. These ASINs will have a history of being merged with the same listings that are merged with the ASINs were are reporting. Also, those ASINs most likely will also have a history of being sold by the same sellers were are reporting. To find these ASINs, simply take the ASINs you found above, copy paste the brand, product name in the search bar > change category dropdown to the category the product is in > search > on the left pane scroll down and check show out of stock. If there are other similar products that were being sold by that brand they will show there. I have found such listings many times. You may find many duplicate products (products that are abandoned).
  5. Also do the above with the scout accounts. You will see many duplicate products under the scout accounts. These are listings that are in the process of having their details changed.
90
user profile
Seller_92JiJJoiPyBWg

There are actually 3 ways that I know of that these sellers are doing this:

  1. What you said: parent-child relationships.
    However, this is done by more amateur sellers. Only requirement is that firstly, item has been out of stock (permanently) and secondly, to change the brand. Only the brand needs to be changed, not all listing details need to be changed. It’s easier to do and easier for Amazon reps to see the violation, as compared to the other methods. When variations are done, the variations names will appear on top of each customer review. It’s not variations (aka parent-child relationships) if there is no variations names above the reviews.
  2. Co-opting a listing and selling in that listing.
    So basically the seller changed ALL the listing details to sell their product. Hence ASIN A will be changed from productA to productB and seller will still be selling on ASIN A. Seller may also co-opt other listings and either create variations with the other listings or merge as “duplicates”. This does provide some level of blockage against detection because many reps don’t even look at the reviews section when they see a case you created about this. They will simply be like it’s your words against the other seller’s words about what the product details should be. Provide proof that you are right.
  3. The most experienced sellers do this. Create a new listing for the product they want to sell. Co-opt other product listings to this product (basically change all details to this new product). Then merge to their new listing as duplicates. Hence they are selling on the actual product ASIN they created while benefiting from reviews of the other ASINs.
    This allows them to “recycle” successfully co-opted listings of other products. More on this towards the end of the post.
    This method makes it so the more incompetent reps at seller support will not be able to understand what is going on with reviews of other products. Why? The actual ASIN you can see in your address bar is the one the seller created to sell. The other ASINs of other products are not visible, even in search. They have basically been “deleted” when merged this way. Firstly, most reps are familiar with this happening with variations. They are confused when they don’t see variations and see that this ASIN you reported has been selling this product all along, they don’t know what to do, simply try to close case without resolution to move on to the next case they can actually resolve and keep their performance metrics up. Case resolution is that it has been transferred to another team, so this case appears closed. Lies - they don’t know what’s wrong and what team to transfer to. Secondly, remember the “other ASINs” of other products had all their product details changed to this product the seller is selling. So even if you instruct the rep to look at the ASINs merged with the one you are reporting, many of them will see the ASINs are the “same product”, hence “properly merged”. I had a rep on the phone who was this incompetent - I soon realized it’s best I hang up and try again. Thirdly, it seems these sellers try to make little small changes to the listing at a time using several accounts - in order to have a super long change history that will potential make it more difficult for Amazon reps to figure out what’s happening. I was on the phone with a rep for a long time who was telling me how much of the change history he had to load through to be able to find what the original listing was.

Some information I have gathered:
1. These seller accounts that you will find in your search are likely not the ones being used to commit violations.
I have explained this in one or more of the threads linked in the OP’s original post. The more experienced sellers who have been able to do this for a long time likely have several seller accounts.
a) They have “disposable” seller accounts. These accounts do not have any monetary value to the seller, they do not make any sales, they are easily replaceable. They are only used to commit these violations - in case Amazon catches the violation, this account gets taken down, the actual account making sales remains protected. You will not find these “disposable” accounts listing the product for sale at buy-box price.
b) They may have several “monetary” accounts. There may be a few reasons for this. Firstly, it may be because of the low quality products that they sell will have high return rates. High return rates causes Amazon to automatically remove the offer from the particular seller. It can take a couple days to reinstate the offer (after sending a plan of action). Hence when that happens, the other monetary account gets the buy-box and the seller doesn’t lose out on a couple days’ sales. Secondly, for “lightning deals” sales. For lightning deals, Amazon does not allow sellers to price a certain percentage higher that the lowest offer over the past few months. Hence with some of the accounts, they offer a price higher than their “normal” price, but then use those high price offers to still price high enough during a lightning deal. The high-scale “monetary” accounts will usually list the product with FBA.
c) They may have a “scout” account or two. These accounts will basically scout for those listings that are out of stock. Then the scout account will list an offer for those listings. This will usually be a super high-priced offer so that they don’t get the buy-box and also so buyers do not buy from them (since they do have actually have the product in case someone buys from them). They do this to kind of “reserve” the listing for their use. So other sellers who are looking for out of stock listings will not see these “reserved” listings since it’s basically not of out stock anymore. You may see these accounts still with an offer on the listing (since their offer gets transferred over when a merge is done) unless they then changed their inventory count to 0. The reason also for these scout accounts instead of just using the “disposable” accounts for this purpose is firstly, to keep a record of the listings they can use, since the “disposable” accounts will lose all access to the list of listings to be used, and secondly, to keep an offer up on the listings (keep them “reserved”) in case the disposable accounts get taken down. The scout accounts usually do not commit violations.
2. The listings that these sellers have successfully co-opted are often recycled.
The reason these sellers first create a new listing and then merge other listings with the new listing (method #3 of hijacking) is so they can recycle the hijacked listings. Often times these sellers are selling low quality products with a high rate of negative reviews. Usually 1-3 stars if they didn’t do the hijacking. Ofcourse, the aim of the hijacking is to keep reviews around 4.5 to get lots of sales. However, as they sell, real actual reviews of the product start flowing in and after months of selling, their overall ratings reach 4.0 stars or lower. They usually will merge more listings with the product to boost the ratings up. However, the number co-opted listings they have is limited, and they are likely selling lots of products where they need to use such co-opted listings of other products. At a certain point, the ASIN they created by itself has accumulated 100’s of 1-3 stars ratings and it makes better sense to them to abandon the ASIN. Remember the reviews of 1-3 stars are tied to that one ASIN, so they can just abandon it. So what they do is they unmerge the ASINs they had merged. The ASINs they had co-opted of other products will retain their high reviews and ratings. They abandon/close the listing they had previously created (which now has 1-3 stars rating), they create a new listing of the same product, do the merge again and once again start at 4.5 ratings. And keep recycling again and again. If they had simply co-opted ASIN1 and listing an offer on ASIN1, new reviews would be tied to that ASIN. In this case the reviews are tied to the ASINs they create and abandon so they can reuse the other ASINs that they had hijacked. This also creates a lot of changes in the change history of these co-opted listings that creates a lot of work for Amazon reps to be able to figure things out. Also, usually this recycling is done with the same type of product. Say seller is trying to sell pest repellent. They co-opted listing to pest-repellent, then when they abandoned the listing it was merged with, then unmerge, they will usually change some details in the title and pictures in the co-opted listing, and then merge with the new listing - and they do this recycling many times. This shows Amazon reps that there were changes made to the listing but as far as they can see in their change history, it was pest repellent for the most part.


I am compiling a list of sellers to report who are doing this. You may help if you wish. I need the information in the following format:

Brand1

Sellername1
ASIN1
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN2
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN3
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products

Sellername2
ASIN1
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN2
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products
ASIN3
-brief explanation of what’s being sold, what did the seller do (variation, co-opting or merge as duplicates)
-screenshots of reviews/Q&A of other products

Let me know if there is a better way to present the information to seller performance.

A lot of the ASINs will have several sellers selling it (usually belonging to the same one seller) although not all of them will have the buy box at a particular time. However they are obviously all in on it. A way to find the ASINs is to go to each of the sellers’ storefront > see products tab. Repeat with each ASIN you find under the tab, ie open ASIN, record it if fraudulent, see sellers selling it, see ASINs being sold by each of those sellers, and repeat. This will give us a HUGE list of ASINs and sellers.

Some other things I’m looking for:

  1. If the same brand has the same (group of) sellers listing under ASINs that have been compromised. It will mean that the seller accounts likely belong to the same one seller. It’s too much coincidence to not be the same seller.
  2. If there a seller account that is on more than one ASIN that has been compromised, it’s obvious it’s not by accident. These are the seller accounts I am looking for.
  3. If the same fraudulent seller account is selling brand1, brand2, it means both brands likely belong to the same seller. Which means that the other brands being sold by seller must also be looked into. If other seller accounts are found selling the other brands, they must also be looked into, it is likely those seller accounts will belong to the same one seller as well.
  4. Remember about the ASINs that sellers eventually abandon and create a new one and reuse co-opted listings? Would be great if we presented a list of those abandoned ASINs. These ASINs will have a history of being merged with the same listings that are merged with the ASINs were are reporting. Also, those ASINs most likely will also have a history of being sold by the same sellers were are reporting. To find these ASINs, simply take the ASINs you found above, copy paste the brand, product name in the search bar > change category dropdown to the category the product is in > search > on the left pane scroll down and check show out of stock. If there are other similar products that were being sold by that brand they will show there. I have found such listings many times. You may find many duplicate products (products that are abandoned).
  5. Also do the above with the scout accounts. You will see many duplicate products under the scout accounts. These are listings that are in the process of having their details changed.
90
Reply
user profile
Seller_3R8e0ZEDKX8g5

big news

00
user profile
Seller_3R8e0ZEDKX8g5

big news

00
Reply
user profile
Seller_Zw8LsZUQSH440

Check B07799VH3X, the dog product turned facial moisturizer. Reported on September 9 and still there.

20
user profile
Seller_Zw8LsZUQSH440

Check B07799VH3X, the dog product turned facial moisturizer. Reported on September 9 and still there.

20
Reply
user profile
Seller_ZTRWwBAvMser0

This problem is still rampant even after new review policies :frowning:

Action towards violators are still very slow, which again they just merge it all again.

10
user profile
Seller_ZTRWwBAvMser0

This problem is still rampant even after new review policies :frowning:

Action towards violators are still very slow, which again they just merge it all again.

10
Reply
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

I just checked the eyelash serum seller

a few days after we posted this … back in September , their hijacked reviews were disconnected from the product

I was Kudoing Amazon then

now just about all the hijacked reviews are BACK!

10
user profile
Seller_gme6aq8vLWpK4

I just checked the eyelash serum seller

a few days after we posted this … back in September , their hijacked reviews were disconnected from the product

I was Kudoing Amazon then

now just about all the hijacked reviews are BACK!

10
Reply
user profile
Seller_bHyOvNtx4PXTh

how to stop some fraud sellers non-verified purchase review abuse problem?They misuse some thousands such fake reviews everyday,such as : B07NV1NC7T , B07N4K65FD,you will find more such fraud sellers for such products.It seems that Amazon acquiesce in such fake reviews.

10
user profile
Seller_bHyOvNtx4PXTh

how to stop some fraud sellers non-verified purchase review abuse problem?They misuse some thousands such fake reviews everyday,such as : B07NV1NC7T , B07N4K65FD,you will find more such fraud sellers for such products.It seems that Amazon acquiesce in such fake reviews.

10
Reply
user profile
Seller_nmZ3PNgBpWo3U

We believe this seller is engaging in fraudulent activity.
New seller, more than 500 listings.

Seller’s name: rulankeji

Link to their storefront:
https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&asin=&isAmazonFulfilled=&isCBA=&marketplaceID=ATVPDKIKX0DER&orderID=&seller=A9HZT97MXZKNS&tab=&vasStoreID=

00
user profile
Seller_nmZ3PNgBpWo3U

We believe this seller is engaging in fraudulent activity.
New seller, more than 500 listings.

Seller’s name: rulankeji

Link to their storefront:
https://www.amazon.com/sp?_encoding=UTF8&asin=&isAmazonFulfilled=&isCBA=&marketplaceID=ATVPDKIKX0DER&orderID=&seller=A9HZT97MXZKNS&tab=&vasStoreID=

00
Reply

Similar Discussions

Similar Discussions

Go to original post