Amazon accepted a return 48 days after purchase
Hi,
Looking for advice on a situation that I suspect many FBA sellers have dealt with.
A customer purchased on March 17, 2026 and Amazon issued a full refund on May 4, 2026 — 48 days after purchase, 18 days outside the standard 30-day return window.
To make things worse, we have strong evidence that Amazon FBA has been re-grading used returns as “sellable” and shipping them to new customers. We have two recent buyer complaints that confirm this:
- "Appears to have been used by someone else. Found hairs all over the item and the package was not sealed."
- "Came used, dirty and obviously previously opened. Disgusting."
These complaints are entirely caused by FBA returning used units back into active inventory — not by anything on our end.
So we are being hit twice:
1. Amazon approves returns outside their own 30-day policy — we lose the reimbursement
2. Amazon resells used returns as new — we get negative reviews
SAFE-T claim is not available for FBA orders. We opened a case with Seller Support but haven’t had a resolution yet.
Has anyone successfully gotten reimbursed in a situation like this? Any specific escalation path or case type that worked for you?
Thanks
Amazon accepted a return 48 days after purchase
Hi,
Looking for advice on a situation that I suspect many FBA sellers have dealt with.
A customer purchased on March 17, 2026 and Amazon issued a full refund on May 4, 2026 — 48 days after purchase, 18 days outside the standard 30-day return window.
To make things worse, we have strong evidence that Amazon FBA has been re-grading used returns as “sellable” and shipping them to new customers. We have two recent buyer complaints that confirm this:
- "Appears to have been used by someone else. Found hairs all over the item and the package was not sealed."
- "Came used, dirty and obviously previously opened. Disgusting."
These complaints are entirely caused by FBA returning used units back into active inventory — not by anything on our end.
So we are being hit twice:
1. Amazon approves returns outside their own 30-day policy — we lose the reimbursement
2. Amazon resells used returns as new — we get negative reviews
SAFE-T claim is not available for FBA orders. We opened a case with Seller Support but haven’t had a resolution yet.
Has anyone successfully gotten reimbursed in a situation like this? Any specific escalation path or case type that worked for you?
Thanks
5 replies
Seller_OvL8C4BJWiuS9
What was the delivery date? Return windows start at delivery date, not order date. Not sure why you are surprised, as Amazon does this all the time. Can't you have returns sent back to you and not back to FBA so you can inspect?
Seller_iobipI6xASRkh
The customer has 30 days after the delivery date to initiate a return, then another 30 days to mail it back. Given it is less than 60 days this is not an abnormal return date.
Seller_nE50Oq6CKvOfR
Unfortunately, this is very common. AMZ gives refunds whenever it feels like it for FBA, be glad you have only experienced 18 days past and not 30-180 days as has happened to many sellers (including us, yes 6 months later.) As far as them putting products back into inventory and calling them new, you need to make sure your settings are correct
Disable Return Evaluation: Navigate to Settings > Fulfillment by Amazon > Customer Returns and disable the "Return Evaluation" feature. This prevents Amazon from automatically deeming used or opened items as "Sellable
also
Automated Unfulfillable Settings: Go to Settings (gear wheel top right) > Fulfillment by Amazon > Automated Unfulfillable Removal Settings and select "Return" or "Dispose".
Yes you will get more stuff back, but then YOU can decide if it's OK to sell or not.
Seller_kIukTwdhvntAp
Well, YOU decided to turn the keys to your business over to Amazon.
As noted by others, there is nothing new or unusual about this and it would have been clear to you if you had read the Forum before you jumped in the river.
You might want to take your 'handle' name to heart and make a Healthy Choice by doing FBM so YOU have some control!
Ken_Amazon
Hi @Seller_HJt8jufCvKBTg,
Thanks for sharing this.
- Regarding the Late Return (48 Days) The standard Amazon return window is 30 days from delivery for customers to initiate a return. However, it's important to note that customers actually have 30 days to initiate the return, plus an additional window to physically drop off the package. Per the FBA reimbursement policy, if a refund is issued and the item is not returned within 60 days (in the US), you may be eligible for automatic reimbursement. I'd recommend monitoring your Reimbursements Report in Seller Central under Reports > Payments to see if a reimbursement is triggered automatically.
- Regarding Used Items Being Resold as New Amazon does have a returns evaluation process where FC associates evaluate the condition of returned items to determine if they're "sellable" or "unsellable". However, you now have the option to disable returns evaluation for your ASINs through FBA Returns Evaluation Settings in Seller Central. When disabled, returned items bypass the grading process and are automatically marked as unsellable — preventing them from being resold as "new". To enable this: Go to Settings > Fulfillment by Amazon > FBA Inventory Evaluation Settings and select "Disable."
- Regarding Negative Reviews from FBA Fulfillment Issues Since these reviews are directly related to FBA's fulfillment process (not your product quality), any seller feedback that is entirely about Amazon's fulfillment should be eligible for strike-through. You can request removal through Feedback Manager in Seller Central. For product reviews, use the "Report abuse" link next to the review if it violates Community Guidelines.
- Next Steps for Your Open Case Keep your existing case open and reference the specific Order ID. If you don't receive resolution, you can request the case be escalated. Make sure to document everything — order dates, refund dates, and the buyer complaints showing the items were clearly used.
I hope this helps point you in the right direction.
Best Regards,
Ken