Exactly the same situation for me. It will allow me to restock two ASIN that have not sold in years. I stopped carrying them because they do not sell. I doubt I have sold ten units in three years. It will not allow me to send any of the sold-out ASIN’s I have sold hundreds of units of.
I sell items that would be considered non-essential, however it is abundantly clear that whatever algorithm is deciding on eligibility is deeply flawed. Amazon needs to revisit this. Rule by algorithm is failing once again.